← Back to the shop
Brown Butter Rye cookies on linen

Brown Butter Rye Chocolate Chunk

Cookie & Brownie Dough

Choose size

$38

Order by Wednesday 6pm for this Friday's delivery.

The grown-up chocolate chip cookie. This cookie started with a question: what if the butter had more to say? So I browned it. Slowly, in a light-colored pan, swirling until the milk solids turned golden and the kitchen smelled like hazelnuts and caramel. Then I swapped part of the flour for stone-milled rye — the kind that makes sourdough bread taste deep and dark — and suddenly the whole recipe got quieter and more interesting. The chocolate stopped shouting. The sweetness stopped being the point. Everything just ... focused. The chocolate is 72% dark, hand-chopped into uneven chunks so some shatter into thin layers and some pool into molten pockets. The rye gives the dough an earthy, almost tannic depth — like the flavor equivalent of a whiskey barrel aged next to chocolate. And the Maldon salt pressed on top while it's still warm cracks the whole thing open. This is the cookie for people who stopped eating chocolate chip cookies at 25 and want a reason to start again.

What they're made of

(all organic unless noted) Stone-milled organic rye flour (Cairnspring Mills), organic all-purpose flour, organic cultured butter (browned), organic dark chocolate 72% (Askinosie), organic dark brown sugar, organic cane sugar, organic eggs (Iacono Farm, East Hampton), pure vanilla extract, baking soda, baking powder, Maldon sea salt.

Preheat oven to 350°F. Place dough balls 2.5 inches apart on a parchment-lined sheet — these spread more than you'd expect. Bake 12–14 minutes until the edges are deeply golden but the centers still look slightly underdone. Press a few flakes of Maldon salt on top while warm. Cool on the tray for 5 minutes. The rye flavor intensifies as it cools, so give them that time — the cookie at minute five is a different (better) cookie than the one at minute one.

Mixed

By hand in a licensed commercial kitchen on the East End.

Delivered

Cold, in a kraft box, every Friday across the Hamptons.

Reviews

Be the first to share your thoughts on Brown Butter Rye Chocolate Chunk.

Loading reviews…